Skip to content

SecurityX or CEH: A Senior Engineering Exam and an Attack-Vocabulary Test

Comparison

SecurityX and CEH both appear in DoD 8140 hiring, but one tests senior engineers on designing defenses and the other tests attack terms. Who should sit which, and why.

Published
Updated
Read time
4 min
C
CertGPS

Not independently reviewed

AI-assisted content. Editorial policy · Suggest a correction

On this page

SecurityX or CEH: A Senior Engineering Exam and an Attack-Vocabulary Test

CEH and SecurityX end up side by side because both count for US Department of Defense (DoD) 8140 work and people buy them to meet a contract, but they sit years apart. EC-Council's CEH checks that you know attack techniques by name and phase, and its self-study route asks for two years in security. CompTIA's SecurityX tests senior engineers on designing and fixing defenses, with ten years in IT recommended. Check which work role your contract or job description names before buying either.

The facts each vendor publishes

SecurityXCEH
IssuerCompTIAEC-Council
ExamCAS-005: up to 90 multiple-choice and performance-based questionsv13 (312-50): 125 multiple-choice questions; optional six-hour Practical with 20 challenges
TimeUp to 165 minutes4 hours
Passing scorePass or fail only; no scaled scoreSet per exam form, between 60% and 85%
Price$544 voucher; $709 with one retake$950 remote voucher plus a $100 application on the self-study route; training packages from $1,699
EligibilityNone required; 10 years in IT including 5 in hands-on security recommendedOfficial EC-Council training, or two years in information security and an approved application
RenewalThree years; 75 CEUs and a $150 fee per cycleThree years; 120 credits and an $80 annual fee

Who each exam is written for

CEH fits a SOC analyst, auditor or system administrator who needs a working vocabulary of attacks across networks, web applications, wireless, cloud and operational technology, and whose employer or contract names it. EC-Council describes CEH v13 as DoD 8140 approved. It doesn't ask you to have tested anything, and the knowledge exam doesn't check whether you can.

SecurityX fits the engineer who decides where the web application firewall goes and writes the cloud identity policies. CompTIA maps it to NICE and DoD 8140 work roles including security architect, systems requirements planner and security control assessor. Someone two or three years into a security job will find most of its outline is work they haven't been given yet; CySA+ or SecurityX covers that gap.

Naming attacks versus designing against them

CEH's blueprint spreads 125 questions across nine domains, and Network and Perimeter Hacking is the largest at 24%, followed by Reconnaissance Techniques at 17%. Expect questions on which tool or flag does what, which scan type a firewall drops, and which phase an action belongs to. The CEH Practical is the only part that asks you to do anything: 20 challenges in six hours on live machines, sold separately for $550.

SecurityX asks what you'd build or fix. Of the 23 objectives in CompTIA's CAS-005 outline, 17 begin "Given a scenario", and Security Engineering carries 31%. The outline has you troubleshoot SAML, OAuth and Kerberos, secure hardware roots of trust and legacy industrial systems, and judge risks in AI adoption using OWASP's Top 10 for LLM Applications. Governance, risk and compliance takes 20%, a domain CEH barely touches.

The topics overlap at the edges, cloud and operational technology among them, but from opposite seats. CEH asks how an attacker gets into an industrial controller. SecurityX asks how you'd segment and monitor it so they can't.

Cost, paperwork and what each counts toward

The self-study CEH costs $1,050 before any training and needs EC-Council to approve your application first, which EC-Council says usually takes five to ten business days. SecurityX is a $544 voucher with no application. Upkeep is cheaper too: EC-Council's $80 annual fee comes to $240 per three years, against CompTIA's $150 per cycle.

For anyone heading toward CISSP, the difference is concrete. SecurityX is on ISC2's list of credentials that waive one of the five years of experience CISSP requires; CEH isn't, and CEH vs CISSP covers what that means. SecurityX also renews every CompTIA certification below it, from CySA+ and PenTest+ down to A+.

Holding both works better in one direction. EC-Council's continuing education policy gives 40 credits for passing a certification exam related to IT security, so a SecurityX pass covers a third of CEH's 120. CompTIA's SecurityX renewal list accepts several EC-Council credentials, including CCISO and the LPT (Master), but not CEH.

Our view

If a contract or job posting names CEH, take it by the cheapest route that satisfies the requirement, and add the Practical if you want the result to show hands-on work. Otherwise, we'd point a senior engineer to SecurityX: it costs about half as much as self-study CEH, tests the job you do, and moves you a year closer to CISSP. A junior analyst wanting an offensive credential would be better served by PenTest+ or CEH than by either of these. A hiring manager who filters for CEH by name will disagree, and if that manager is the one hiring you, their view wins.

Sources (11)