
A level 2 analyst in a security operations center (SOC) is closer to both of these than the job titles suggest. CompTIA writes CySA+ for about four years of SOC or vulnerability work, and ISACA counts security work toward CISA's five years. Both are within reach, so the choice turns on whether you want to keep working the alert queue or start testing whether the queue, the logging and the incident process work at all.
CySA+ and CISA compared
| CySA+ | CISA | |
|---|---|---|
| Issuer | CompTIA | ISACA |
| Version | CS0-004 since June 23, 2026; English CS0-003 retires December 22, 2026 | Outline effective August 2024 |
| Format | Multiple choice and performance-based | Multiple choice, four options, one best answer |
| Questions | Up to 85 | 150 |
| Time | 165 minutes | 4 hours |
| Passing score | 750 on a 100 to 900 scale | 450 on a scaled range of 200 to 800 |
| Price | $439 voucher; $579 with one retake | US$575 members, US$760 non-members, plus a US$50 application fee |
| Experience | None required; about four years as a level 2 SOC or vulnerability analyst recommended | Five years of qualifying IS audit, control, assurance or security work; up to three years waived, with at least two years in a CISA domain |
| Renewal | Three years; 60 CEUs and a $150 fee | US$45 (members) or US$85 a year; 20 CPE hours a year, 120 per three years |
Analysts, auditors, and the analyst who might become one
CySA+ suits the level 1 analyst ready to move up, the vulnerability analyst who runs scanners and argues about patch order, and the administrator who has become the team's incident handler. CompTIA lists it under US Department of Defense 8140 requirements, which matters on a defense contract.
CISA suits internal audit teams, audit firms and compliance staff whose work is testing controls they don't operate. ISACA announced CISA's approval under DoDM 8140.03 in May 2024, so both work for defense roles; they just map to different jobs.
Some analysts sit between the two. If the parts of the job you like are writing the metrics report, mapping detections to a control framework or preparing evidence for the external auditors, the audit side may suit you. If it's pulling apart a packet capture, stay with detection and take CySA+, then look at GCIH or our SOC analyst career ladder.
The same incident from two chairs
CySA+ makes you handle the incident. CompTIA's V4 outline gives Security Operations 34% and Incident Response and Management 24%, and six of its 15 objectives start "Given a scenario". Objective 1.3 names more than 20 tools, from Zeek and Suricata to YARA and CyberChef, and you're expected to read EVTX files and spot a malicious PowerShell line.
CISA asks whether the organization handles incidents well. Its protection domain, weighted 26% by ISACA, includes security incident response management, monitoring logs and tools, and evidence collection and forensics. The tasks behind it read "evaluate the organization's problem and incident management program" and "evaluate the organization's log management program". You'll be asked what an auditor should request, sample or report, never which Suricata rule to write.
The closest overlap is in reporting. CySA+'s smallest domain, 16% in CompTIA's outline, lists the metrics a SOC reports, such as mean time to detect and respond. CISA has a task to evaluate the monitoring and reporting of IT key performance and key risk indicators. An analyst who has built those dashboards already knows what an auditor will ask of them.
Version timing, renewal and experience overlap
If you're taking CySA+ this autumn, decide the version first. The English CS0-003 exam retires on December 22, 2026, and CompTIA ties vouchers to an exam series, so most candidates should prepare for CS0-004.
The renewal rules overlap as well. CompTIA's renewal page for CySA+ lists CISA as worth the full 60 CEUs, provided it's earned or renewed during your three-year cycle, though the $150 CE fee still applies. An analyst who moves into audit and earns CISA keeps CySA+ current without further CEUs. Going the other way, ISACA's CPE policy gives two CPE hours per exam hour for passing a related exam aligned with the CISA outline, so a passed 165-minute CySA+ attempt would be worth five and a half hours.
Your SOC years count toward CISA's five, since ISACA's experience definition includes security work. CySA+ itself waives nothing on the CISA side, where ISACA lists specific work, education and credential substitutions. It does waive a year of CISSP experience; CISA doesn't.
Our view
For a working analyst, CySA+ comes first. It's cheaper, describes the job you already do, and at about four years recommended it fits mid-SOC careers well. Take CISA when you've decided to move into assurance, not as a reward for tenure: it tests an auditor's judgment, which is a separate skill from detection. The pair makes the most sense for someone heading into IT audit with a security operations specialty, because CISA then keeps CySA+ renewed and the SOC background gives the auditor first-hand knowledge of the controls they'll be testing.
Sources (15)
-
ISACA CISA certification application: domain-mapped work, minimum two years, work and education substitutions including CIMA and ACCA, checked October 2026
-
CompTIA CySA+: CS0-003 retirement dates, checked October 2026
-
CompTIA CySA+ V4: CS0-004 launch, format, score, recommended experience, weights, DoD 8140, voucher prices, checked October 2026
-
CompTIA CySA+ CS0-004 exam objectives (PDF): scenario objectives, tool list, reporting metrics, checked October 2026
-
CompTIA CySA+ renewal requirements: ISACA CISA listed at 60 CEUs, checked October 2026
-
CompTIA: Earn a non-CompTIA IT industry certification: earned or renewed within the cycle, CE fees apply, checked October 2026
-
CompTIA Continuing Education Renewal Fees: $150 fee per three-year cycle, checked October 2026
-
CompTIA Voucher Terms: series-specific vouchers, checked October 2026
-
ISACA: CISA certification: prices and application fee, checked October 2026
-
ISACA: Certification Exam Candidate Guide 2026 (PDF): 150 questions, 4 hours, scaled score, experience including security work, CISA outline and tasks, checked October 2026
-
ISACA Support: requirements to become CISA certified: waiver categories, checked October 2026
-
ISACA: Maintain your CISA: annual fees and CPE hours, checked October 2026
-
ISACA: CPE Policy (PDF): two CPE hours per exam hour for passing related examinations, checked October 2026
-
ISACA press release: CISA and CISM approved for DoD cyber workforce: May 2024 DoDM 8140.03 approval, checked October 2026
-
ISC2 CISSP Experience Requirements: CySA+ on the waiver list, CISA not, checked October 2026