
ISACA says more than 111,000 people have earned the CISM since 2002, and its CISM page says 48,000-plus hold it now. Those differently dated counts show why a renewal rate cannot be inferred from holder totals; no exam body we checked publishes the rate itself. Each vendor's lapse rules then decide how long you have before an unpaid fee or a missing CPE costs you the exam.
Earned versus held
ISACA publishes two kinds of count. In a September 10, 2026 press release about the new CISM outline, it said CISM had been "earned by more than 111,000 professionals since its inception in 2002"; its CISM credential page says "48K+ professionals hold CISM." For CISA, a July 2025 release gave "more than 219,000" earned since 1978, while the CISA page says "151K+" hold it.
Taken at face value, about 43% of everyone who has earned a CISM still holds it, and about 69% for CISA. Those ratios need care. ISACA doesn't say how it counts holders or when the page figures were last updated, and the gap mixes people who let the credential lapse with people who retired or died, which matters more for a credential first awarded in 1978.
ISACA's rules show how a lapse happens. Holders report at least 20 CPE hours a year and 120 over three years, pay an annual fee of US$45 for members or US$85 for others, and face a random audit each year. Under its CPE policy, anyone who doesn't comply has the credential revoked and must pass the exam and apply again; an appeal is possible, with a US$50 reinstatement fee once the revocation is more than 60 days old, but not after three years.
What ISC2's membership count shows
ISC2 counts every certified holder in good standing as a member, and publishes a year-end total of members and associates. Its 2025 annual report gives 167,396 at the end of 2021, 185,735 in 2022, 226,642 in 2023, 262,874 in 2024 and 270,764 at the end of 2025. The 2025 rise was 3%, or 7,890 people, against 36,232 the year before.
A net membership change mixes entrants and departures, including associates; one existing member adding a certification does not increase that headcount. These totals do not disclose renewal rates. The 2025 slowdown could come from fewer new members, more lapses, or both. The count also includes holders of the entry-level CC, more than 65,000 of whom came through ISC2's free program by its own figures, and who pay a $50 annual fee to keep it.
When each credential lapses
These rules decide whether a missed deadline costs you a fee or a new exam.
| Certification | What keeps it current | After a missed deadline |
|---|---|---|
| CISSP and other ISC2 certifications | 120 CPE credits per three years for CISSP and a $135 annual fee | 90-day grace period, then suspension for up to two years, then termination |
| CISM and CISA | 20 CPE hours a year, 120 over three, and an annual fee | Revocation; reinstatement appeals within three years, otherwise a new exam |
| Security+ | 50 CEUs and $150 every three years, or a qualifying exam or higher certification | 30-day grace period, then you must pass the current exam |
| GSEC | 36 CPEs and $499 every four years, or passing the current exam | No published rule; GIAC asks expired holders to email its renewal team |
| OSCP | OSCP never expires; OSCP+ extension needs annual coverage plus 120 CPEs or a qualifying exam; $799 recertification can instead earn a new three-year certification without annual fees | 90-day grace period for OSCP+, after which you keep OSCP |
Of the published rules, ISC2's are the most forgiving: a suspended member can pay the current-year AMF and submit the outstanding CPE credits to return, but may not use the credential meanwhile. A terminated member can seek reinstatement with 120 CPE credits earned within 12 months, including at least five in each domain and 40 in the primary practice domain, or pass the exam again. CompTIA is the strictest. Once the 30 days pass, the only route back is the current exam.
Why renewal matters more in some jobs
In US defense work, a lapsed certification is a compliance problem as well as a gap on a résumé. CompTIA's renewal FAQ notes that the Defense Department stopped recognizing its older "good for life" certifications on January 1, 2011, and that certifications earned since then must stay current through its continuing education program, with the same rules applying to government contractors. GIAC's summary of the DoD 8140 rules lists annual maintenance through certification CPEs or 20 hours a year. Our article on moving from the military into civilian security covers those roles.
Reading a holder count
When a vendor quotes how many people hold a certification, check whether it means earned since launch or currently active. CyberSeek, the job-market tool run by NIST's NICE program with Lightcast and CompTIA, lists current US holders: 91,765 for CISSP, 35,812 for CISA and 20,300 for CISM in its latest data. Those can be compared with each other; a cumulative figure from a press release can't be compared with any of them.
Our view: if you hold a credential you no longer need, letting it lapse is a reasonable choice, but know which rule you're under first. An ISC2 holder has more than two years to change their mind; a CompTIA holder has 30 days. The fees are part of the long-run cost covered in our look at certification ROI studies.
Sources (17)
- ISACA press release: CISM exam content outline update: September 10, 2026, more than 111,000 earned since 2002, checked October 2026
- ISACA: CISM certification: 48K+ professionals hold CISM, checked October 2026
- ISACA press release: ISACA Introduces the CISA Associate: July 10, 2025, more than 219,000 earned since 1978, checked October 2026
- ISACA: CISA certification: 151K+ professionals hold CISA, checked October 2026
- ISACA: CPE Policy (PDF): annual audits, revocation, reinstatement fee and three-year limit, checked October 2026
- ISACA: Maintain your CISM: CPE hours and maintenance fees, checked October 2026
- ISC2 2025 Annual Report (PDF): membership 2021 to 2025, 3% growth, CC program figures, checked October 2026
- ISC2 Membership Policies and Procedures: CPE requirement, 90-day grace period, suspension, termination and reinstatement, checked October 2026
- ISC2 Annual Maintenance Fees: $135 annual fee and $50 CC-only fee, checked October 2026
- CompTIA Certification Renewal Policy: three-year validity, 30-day grace period, retaking the latest exam, checked October 2026
- CompTIA Continuing Education Program FAQ: good-for-life certifications and DoD recognition, contractors, checked October 2026
- CompTIA Continuing Education Renewal Fees: $150 fee and fee-free routes, checked October 2026
- GIAC renewal: 36 CPEs over four years, expired certification FAQ, checked October 2026
- GIAC pricing and fees: $499 renewal fee, checked October 2026
- OffSec CPE Program and Annual Maintenance Handbook: OSCP+ CPEs, fees, recertification exam, grace period, checked October 2026
- GIAC: DoD 8140: annual maintenance under DoD 8140, checked October 2026
- CyberSeek heatmap: current US holders of CISSP, CISA and CISM, checked October 2026