Skip to content

CGRC (Formerly CAP) or SecurityX: The Authorization Package or the Architecture Behind It

Comparison

CGRC or CompTIA SecurityX: ISC2's exam for taking a system through authorization against CompTIA's senior engineering exam, and how one renews the other.

Published
Updated
Read time
4 min
C
CertGPS

Not independently reviewed

AI-assisted content. Editorial policy · Suggest a correction

On this page

CGRC (Formerly CAP) or SecurityX: The Authorization Package or the Architecture Behind It

CompTIA lists "security control assessor" among the DoD 8140 work roles for SecurityX, and assessing controls sits at the center of ISC2's CGRC, the credential called CAP until February 2023. That is roughly where the overlap ends. SecurityX is for the senior engineer who designs and troubleshoots defenses. CGRC is for the person who takes one system through authorization and keeps it there. Choose by what you hand over at the end of a project: a working design or an authorization package.

The facts each issuer publishes

CGRCSecurityX
IssuerISC2CompTIA
ExamFixed length; multiple choice and advanced item typesCAS-005; multiple choice and performance-based
Questions125Up to 90
Time3 hoursUp to 165 minutes
Passing score700 out of 1000Pass or fail only, no scaled score
Price (US)$599$544 voucher
ExperienceTwo years in its domains, requiredNone required; ten years in IT, five in hands-on security, recommended
Renewal60 CPE credits per three years and a $135 annual fee75 CEUs and a $150 fee per three-year cycle

Two different seniorities

SecurityX fits a senior engineer or architect: the person deciding where the web application firewall and API gateway sit, writing cloud identity policies, or tracing a TLS mismatch across a hybrid network. CompTIA's recommendation of ten years in IT is only a recommendation, but the exam is written for that reader.

CGRC fits an information system security officer, a control assessor or a GRC analyst, usually on US federal systems or for a contractor. Its two years are a hard requirement. Pass without them and you become an Associate of ISC2, with three years to earn the experience. ISC2 defines that experience as work "performed in pursuit of information system authorization" or the direct application of security risk management knowledge, so years of architecture work don't automatically count. CGRC can be a first specialist credential two years into GRC work, where SecurityX arrives well into a technical career.

What each exam spends its time on

CompTIA's CAS-005 objectives give Governance, Risk, and Compliance 20% of the exam and the other 80% to Security Architecture (27%), Security Engineering (31%) and Security Operations (22%). Seventeen of its 23 objectives begin "Given a scenario", and the performance-based items reward people who have fixed SAML federation, DKIM records or a broken trust policy for real. Its governance objectives name COBIT, ITIL, NIST CSF, the ISO/IEC 27000 series, SOC 2 and PCI DSS. They don't name the NIST Risk Management Framework or SP 800-53. The phrase "continuous authorization" does appear, under Zero Trust in objective 2.6, where it means re-checking a user's access, not an authorizing official's decision about a system.

CGRC is almost all governance, and most of it comes after controls are chosen. In ISC2's outline, implementation, assessment, the compliance decision and ongoing maintenance make up 60% of the exam. Questions turn on order and ownership. Who signs the risk acceptance? What goes into the POA&M? When does a change need the change control board? The vocabulary is federal (authorizing officials, inherited and common controls, FedRAMP, CMMC, FISMA) even when a question names ISO or COBIT. The exam has no performance-based items.

A SecurityX holder sitting CGRC will find Domain 4, implementation, familiar and most of the rest new. A CGRC holder facing SecurityX has a foundation for its 20% governance domain, but must still study the engineering and architecture objectives.

How they count toward each other

This pair is unusual in that one certification renews the other. CompTIA's SecurityX renewal list accepts a CGRC pass for 75 CEUs, the full three-year requirement, so an engineer who moves into assessment work and earns CGRC keeps SecurityX current with the $150 fee.

Toward CISSP, both are on ISC2's list of credentials that satisfy one year of the five-year experience requirement, and the waiver is one year whichever you hold. For defense work, ISC2 lists CGRC as approved under DoDM 8140.03, and CompTIA maps SecurityX to DoD 8140 roles including security architect and security control assessor.

If you're weighing a management credential instead, our CISM vs SecurityX comparison covers that route, and CISA vs CGRC covers the audit side.

Our view

For most readers only one of these fits the job they have now. The case for both is a senior engineer who has started assessing systems for authorization. That person should take CGRC. They'll learn the federal sequence that SecurityX skips, and the pass renews SecurityX. We'd argue the reverse move is weaker: a CGRC holder gains little from SecurityX unless they're heading into architecture, and $544 is a lot to spend on a 20% overlap. Some assessors would disagree, on the grounds that an assessor who can read a cloud policy tests controls rather than interviewing about them. If that is how your organization assesses, SecurityX earns its place.

Sources (12)